10 Common Myths About Background Checks

Background checks are a crucial part of hiring, but there are a lot of myths about how they work, what information they reveal, and how they affect hiring decisions. These myths lead to wrong ideas about things like privacy, accuracy, and the law. Other people think that background checks only look at criminal records, while others think that they are able to see any personal information.

Here are ten common myths about background checks:

Background Checks Take Too Long: People often believe that background checks take too long, even though most are completed within a few days, depending on the service and the level of detail in the check.

Background Checks Are Only for Pre-Employment: Background checks are done before hiring, promotion, security clearances, and making sure employees follow the rules all the time.

Employers Use Them to Reject Candidates: A background check helps confirm credentials and figure out potential risks, but it doesn’t instantly rule out candidates without giving them a fair chance.

A Criminal Record Always Disqualifies You: Many companies look at the type of offense, the amount of time that has passed, and how it relates to the job instead of automatically disqualifying a candidate.

Background Checks Delay Hiring Significantly: Most background checks are done in a decent amount of time, and they don’t really slow down the hiring process when they’re done right.

All Providers Use the Same ID Verification: Different background check companies use different identification verification methods, and the quality of checks varies depending on the systems and processes they use.

All Providers Give Identical Results: The accuracy and completeness of reports vary since different providers use different databases.

Small Businesses Don’t Need Background Checks: Background checks are helpful for all companies, even small ones, to lower workplace risks.

Employers Get MVR Reports Instantly: It takes time to get Motor Vehicle Reports (MVRs) because they depend on how long it takes each state to handle them and give people access to their driving records.

All Providers Are Equally Trustworthy: Background check providers are not all reliable because they use different data sources and give different levels of accuracy.

1. Background Checks Take Too Long

Background checks take too long is a myth that comes from thinking that the process is slow and causes hiring choices to be put off. It is a myth because delays usually happen when records need to be checked manually, like with court papers or international checks.

2. Background Checks Are Only for Pre-Employment

Background checks are only for pre-employment is a myth that background checks are only done during the hiring process. In fact, many fields need background checks on a regular basis or continuously to make sure that employees continue to meet company and government standards. It is a myth because employers in industries like healthcare, finance, and transportation re-screen employees to find possible risks, like new criminal records or changes in financial situation.

3. Employers Use Them to Reject Candidates

Employers use background checks to reject candidates is a myth that thinks screenings are only done to get rid of applicants. In reality, background checks aren’t used to rule out candidates automatically. They’re used to confirm information, evaluate risk, and make sure the workplace is safe and follows the rules. It is a myth because many employers look at results as a whole, taking into account things like the type of offense, how it relates to the job, and how long it has been since the event.

4. A Criminal Record Always Disqualifies You

A criminal record always disqualifies you is a myth that says anyone with a criminal record is not able to get a job. In reality, many employers look at a person’s criminal history on an individual basis, taking into account things like how bad the crime was, how it relates to the job, and how long it’s been since the crime. It is a myth because fair hiring laws, like the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) guidelines and Ban-the-Box regulations, require employers to do individual tests instead of just turning down applicants with records.

5. Background Checks Delay Hiring Significantly

Background checks delay hiring significantly is a myth based on a false assumption that background checks take weeks to finish and slow down the hiring process. Delays usually happen when things like court records or foreign screenings need to be checked by hand. It is a myth because most screening companies use cutting-edge technology, direct database access, and automated procedures to get findings faster.

6. All Providers Use the Same ID Verification

All providers use the same ID verification is a myth that all background check companies use the same verification processes to confirm a candidate’s identity. In reality, various service providers use various techniques, tools, and data sources to make sure a candidate is who they say they are. It is a myth because some use government-issued IDs and others use biometric authentication, AI-powered facial recognition, or multiple-step verification methods to make sure they are accurate.

7. All Providers Give Identical Results

All providers give identical results is a myth that is based on the idea that background check companies use the same databases and give the same reports. In reality, different providers use different data sources, search methods, and verification processes, which cause results to be different. It’s not true because some screening companies have direct access to national and foreign records, while others use third-party aggregators, which makes the information less accurate and incomplete.

8. Small Businesses Don’t Need Background Checks

Small businesses don’t need background checks is a myth that assumes background checks are not necessary for small businesses. In reality, background checks are necessary for all businesses to have a safe, reliable, and law-abiding staff. It is a myth because small companies are just as likely to face risks like fraud, theft, and lawsuits for negligent hiring.

9. Employers Get MVR Reports Instantly

Employers get MVR (Motor Vehicle Records) reports instantly is a myth that assumes MVR checks are acquired instantly. In reality, it takes longer for some reports because of differences in state requirements, data availability, and verification methods, while other reports are processed fast. It is a myth because MVR reports are based on state-level systems that are updated at different times and sometimes need extra information or manual reviews.

10. All Providers Are Equally Trustworthy

All providers are equally trustworthy is a myth that all background check companies adhere to the same moral guidelines and deliver accurate results. In reality, providers are very different when it comes to how accurate their data is, how well they follow the law, and how well they treat their customers. It is a myth because other businesses do not fully adhere to the Fair Credit Reporting Act’s (FCRA) rules exactly, which leads to legal problems or mistakes in the reports.

What is a Background Screening?

A background screening is the process of confirming a person’s personal, professional, and financial past to determine their trustworthiness and suitability for a particular position or role. The process is often referred to as a background screening or pre-employment screening, and employers use it to verify qualifications, criminal records, job histories, and other important information. Background screenings are used to screen potential tenants, process loan applications, and issue licenses. These checks are necessary to lower risks, enhance safety, and comply with government rules.

What does Background Checks achieve?

Background checks verify a candidate’s qualifications and personal background, reducing potential workplace risks. It helps employers ensure that the information job candidates provide is accurate, including their work history, education, and criminal records, allowing them to identify any potential red flags that may impact safety, trustworthiness, or job performance.

What are the Laws Governing Employee Background Checks?

The laws governing background checks include:

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA): The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) controls how background checks are done and makes sure that the person giving permission signs a written consent before any negative steps are taken because of the report.

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) Guidelines: The guidelines say that biased actions must not be used during background checks, and they must not affect certain groups more than others.

State-Specific Laws: Specific laws in each state put extra limits on who is able to see or use certain types of information during background checks, like credit records.

Data Protection and Privacy Laws: Employers must be required to handle personal data information they get from background checks safely and only use it for the relevant purposes.

Ban-the-Box Laws: One of the laws governing employee background checks is ban the box laws. It restricts companies from asking about criminal records on initial job applications to provide equal opportunity to applicants.

How do Background Checks Benefit Companies?

Background checks benefit companies by giving them important information about a candidate’s skills, past performance, and possible risks, which helps them make informed hiring choices. The five primary benefits of background checks are risk mitigation, enhanced workplace safety, compliance, reduced hiring costs, and improved company reputation. Background checks help businesses protect their assets, streamline the hiring process, and foster a safer and more effective workplace.

How does Shield Screening assist employers with Background checks?

Shield Screening assists employers with background checks by providing a wide range of screening services that simplify the hiring process, all in accordance with applicable laws. These services include checks for criminal records, proof of work and education, credit reports, drug tests, motor vehicle records (MVR), and others. Shield Screening services provides committed customer service to help throughout the process, while improving the candidate experience by keeping communication open, which makes the background check process easier for everyone.

Complete Form to Schedule a Consultation

Questions?
Call us at 1-800-260-3738

This material is for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice, guidance, or counsel. Readers and/or companies need to consult their own legal counsel about their compliance responsibilities under the FCRA and applicable state and local laws. Shield Screening disclaims any responsibility or damages associated with or resulting from the information provided.

Scroll to Top